How far do most restaurants and cafes sit from The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village?

Many named restaurants and cafes are within roughly 400 meters of The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village. Spots like The Babylon Bean, 90 West Main Street, The James, Babylon Burger, Fancy Lee, Glen’s Dinette, Mulberry Street, Tricia’s Cafe, Post Office Cafe, and Juice N Blendz are all mapped within about 150 meters, while others such as Swell Taco, Del Fuego, Gemelli’s, Gemelli, and Jack Jack’s Coffee House are still walkable but a bit farther away.

Are there Italian restaurants within a short walk of The Argyle Theatre?

Yes. Several nearby places are categorized as Italian restaurants, including 90 West Main Street very close to the theatre, Mulberry Street on East Main Street, and Gemelli’s and Gemelli farther east along East Main Street. All are within a walkable distance of The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village.

Where can I find coffee or a light cafe option near the theatre?

The Babylon Bean on Fire Island Avenue is mapped about 63 meters from the theatre and categorized as a cafe with free internet access. Post Office Cafe on West Main Street and Juice N Blendz on Deer Park Avenue are both around 136 meters away and tagged as cafes, while Jack Jack’s Coffee House on Deer Park Avenue is roughly 418 meters from the venue.

Is there a bar near The Argyle Theatre for a drink before or after the show?

Mary Caroll’s on Deer Park Avenue is categorized as a bar and is approximately 258 meters from The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village. Depending on what they serve, some nearby cafes and restaurants, such as Post Office Cafe, may also offer drinks, so you can choose a spot that fits your plans.

Do I need reservations for restaurants near The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village?

Available mapping data lists restaurant names, locations, and broad cuisine categories but does not specify reservation policies. Because Babylon Village has many dining options close together and demand can change with show schedules, you should check each restaurant’s current reservation and walk-in practices directly before you go.

Are any nearby restaurants or cafes noted as wheelchair accessible?

The Babylon Bean and Tricia’s Cafe are both tagged with wheelchair access in available mapping data, indicating step-free access has been recorded there. However, accessibility features can change over time, so it is best to confirm current access details directly with the venue if this is important for your visit.

Restaurants and dining near The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village

Planning a meal near the Argyle Theatre before your show

The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village stands on West Main Street a walkable downtown, with a tight cluster of restaurants, cafés, and bars within a few hundred meters. This guide focuses on named spots close enough to reach on foot so you can decide whether to sit down for a meal, grab a quick coffee, or meet friends for a drink before or after your performance.

Distances are approximate walking distances from the theatre, giving you a sense of how far you’ll stroll from the marquee to your table. Because hours, menus, and reservation policies change over time, always confirm current details directly with any place you plan to visit, especially if you’re timing your visit around curtain or planning a pre-show gathering.

Map of nearby restaurants

Venue
Restaurant

Map data © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap · © OpenStreetMap contributors via Geoapify

Very close options within about 120 meters

If you want to stay almost on the theatre’s doorstep, several food and drink options are within roughly a one- to two-minute walk. These are convenient if you prefer to arrive in Babylon, park or take the train, and then keep everything on the same block or the next corner.

The Babylon Bean
About 63 m from the theatre on Fire Island Avenue; a cafe-style spot listed with free internet access and wheelchair access.
Thejamesbabylon / The James
Around 73–74 m away at 21 Fire Island Avenue; mapped as a restaurant, with The James tagged as a steak house.
Babylon Burger
Approximately 78 m from the venue on Deer Park Avenue; listed as a restaurant, with Glen’s Dinette nearby also tagged for burgers.
Fancy Lee
About 80 m away at 101 West Main Street; categorized as an Asian restaurant.
Glen's Dinette
Roughly 113 m from the theatre on West Main Street; identified as a restaurant with a burger category tag.
Mulberry Street
Around 117 m away at 44 East Main Street; listed as an Italian restaurant.
Tricia's Cafe
About 118 m from the theatre on East Main Street; tagged for American and burger options and noted as wheelchair accessible.

Cafes and coffee spots near the theatre

If you are arriving early for a matinee or just want a lighter option before curtain, several cafes are within a short walk of the Argyle Theatre. These can work well for a quick drink or a simple bite, depending on what each location offers.

The Babylon Bean
Roughly 63 m away on Fire Island Avenue; listed as a cafe with free internet access and step-free access indicated by a wheelchair tag.
Post Office Cafe
About 136 m from the theatre on West Main Street; categorized as a cafe.
Juice N Blendz
Around 136 m away on Deer Park Avenue; mapped as a cafe, which may be useful for smoothies or lighter fare depending on their current menu.
Jack Jack’s Coffee House
Approximately 418 m from the venue on Deer Park Avenue; tagged as a coffee-focused cafe, still walkable if you do not mind a slightly longer stroll.

Italian and pizza-focused restaurants nearby

Several restaurants near The Argyle Theatre are categorized as Italian, giving you options if you are in the mood for pasta or similar dishes. These range from spots just across the street to others a bit farther along East Main Street.

Mulberry Street
Roughly 117 m away at 44 East Main Street; also tagged as an Italian restaurant within a short walk.
Gemelli's
Around 262 m from the venue at 115 East Main Street; identified as an Italian restaurant a little farther east from the theatre.
Gemelli
Approximately 350 m away at 175 East Main Street; another Italian-tagged restaurant, still walkable but farther than the West Main and Deer Park Avenue options.

Mexican and other international choices within walking distance

If you prefer Mexican or Asian-inspired dishes before a performance, Babylon Village offers several mapped options within a few hundred meters of the theatre. These can be useful if your group wants something different from the nearby Italian and burger-focused spots.

Fancy Lee
About 80 m from the theatre on West Main Street; categorized as an Asian restaurant, making it one of the closest international options.
Swell Taco
Roughly 203 m away on Deer Park Avenue; listed as a Mexican restaurant within a short walk north of the venue.
Del Fuego
Approximately 247 m from the theatre on Deer Park Avenue; another Mexican restaurant option close to Swell Taco.

Burgers, American fare, and casual bites

Several nearby restaurants are tagged for burgers or American-style food, which can work well if your group wants familiar options close to the theatre. Distances here are still short enough to keep you within a comfortable walk of showtime.

Babylon Burger
About 78 m from The Argyle Theatre on Deer Park Avenue; mapped simply as a restaurant but named for burgers.
Glen's Dinette
Roughly 113 m away on West Main Street; categorized as a restaurant with a burger tag, indicating burgers are part of the offering.
Tricia's Cafe
Around 118 m from the venue on East Main Street; tagged for American and burger options and noted as wheelchair accessible.
Ginos
Approximately 239 m from the theatre on Deer Park Avenue; listed as a restaurant without a more specific cuisine tag, so check directly if you have particular preferences.

Bars and places to meet for a drink

If you are mainly looking for a drink before or after a show, there are bars and bar-forward venues within walking distance of The Argyle Theatre. These can also be meeting points if your group is arriving from different directions.

Mary Caroll’s
About 258 m from the theatre on Deer Park Avenue; categorized specifically as a bar.
Post Office Cafe
Roughly 136 m away on West Main Street; tagged as a cafe, and many visitors use cafe-style venues as casual drink or meetup spots depending on what they serve.

Planning tips: timing, accessibility, and what to confirm

Because so many restaurants and cafes are within a few hundred meters of The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village, you can reasonably plan to park or arrive by train once and then walk to your chosen spot. Some places, such as The Babylon Bean and Tricia’s Cafe, are tagged as wheelchair accessible, but if accessibility is important for your group it is still wise to call ahead and confirm current conditions.

For any restaurant, bar, or cafe listed here, verify opening hours, menu options, and whether they accept or recommend reservations for your show date. Building in extra time between your meal and curtain gives you a buffer for walking back to the theatre, using restrooms, and finding your seats without rushing.

Frequently Asked Questions

How far do most restaurants and cafes sit from The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village?: Many named restaurants and cafes are within roughly 400 meters of The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village. Spots like The Babylon Bean, 90 West Main Street, The James, Babylon Burger, Fancy Lee, Glen’s Dinette, Mulberry Street, Tricia’s Cafe, Post Office Cafe, and Juice N Blendz are all mapped within about 150 meters, while others such as Swell Taco, Del Fuego, Gemelli’s, Gemelli, and Jack Jack’s Coffee House are still walkable but a bit farther away.
Are there Italian restaurants within a short walk of The Argyle Theatre?: Yes. Several nearby places are categorized as Italian restaurants, including 90 West Main Street very close to the theatre, Mulberry Street on East Main Street, and Gemelli’s and Gemelli farther east along East Main Street. All are within a walkable distance of The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village.
Where can I find coffee or a light cafe option near the theatre?: The Babylon Bean on Fire Island Avenue is mapped about 63 meters from the theatre and categorized as a cafe with free internet access. Post Office Cafe on West Main Street and Juice N Blendz on Deer Park Avenue are both around 136 meters away and tagged as cafes, while Jack Jack’s Coffee House on Deer Park Avenue is roughly 418 meters from the venue.
Is there a bar near The Argyle Theatre for a drink before or after the show?: Mary Caroll’s on Deer Park Avenue is categorized as a bar and is approximately 258 meters from The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village. Depending on what they serve, some nearby cafes and restaurants, such as Post Office Cafe, may also offer drinks, so you can choose a spot that fits your plans.
Do I need reservations for restaurants near The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village?: Available mapping data lists restaurant names, locations, and broad cuisine categories but does not specify reservation policies. Because Babylon Village has many dining options close together and demand can change with show schedules, you should check each restaurant’s current reservation and walk-in practices directly before you go.
Are any nearby restaurants or cafes noted as wheelchair accessible?: The Babylon Bean and Tricia’s Cafe are both tagged with wheelchair access in available mapping data, indicating step-free access has been recorded there. However, accessibility features can change over time, so it is best to confirm current access details directly with the venue if this is important for your visit.